The Commodification of Crystals is Stupid
Don’t buy gemstones. It’s bad for the earth, bad for your spirituality, and totally contradictory to the lessons that stones or crystal healing can offer.

When you take plant medicine in ceremony, you first ask the plant, thank the plant, and prepare yourself in a variety of ways for the sacrament. The medicine works on you, mind, body, spirit and beyond, and passes through your system, leaving you transformed.
But then why are sacred crystals from within the earth of Planet Earth itself starting to be treated like plastic jewelry?
If you have ever used crystals in your healing practice (anything from rose quartz, to jasper, to moldavite, to malachite, to even mineral healing such as copper) then you might be aware of their power. If you are trained in Reiki healing, or otherwise practiced and mature in your energy sensitivity, then you know the gravity and seriousness with which crystal or gemstone healing can occur.
The hierarchy of power in any setting is damaging and usually inaccurate. From species hierarchy (which animals we do or don’t eat,) to calling some plants weeds (dandelions are more healing than dahlias, overall,) we are increasingly eager to find lines in the sand. Gems are no different.
Most people are willing to jump on trends or common belief to just feel safer — mostly so that they don’t have to worry about making additional choices themselves. To give away your choice is to avoid making a wrong choice. This is understandably appealing. Trust the online store selling the crystals to tell you their uses. Follow their accounts to know which crystals to buy more of or to buy next…
Larger crystals are not more powerful. Chairs or large decorations made out of amethyst are wasteful and greedy. If you don’t actively work with your crystals and treat them like family or pets, then you should never, ever buy any more. Until you know and understand each crystal, do not increase the demand and then, as such, increasing the mining of crystals.
If you are going to buy a crystal, you are going to be buying it after it was taken from its home and birthplace, of the dirt or cave or environment in which is was grown, by Planet Earth, over thousands of years.
Buying extracted crystals (all crystals that you didn’t find on the ground yourself, essentially) is like buying the teeth of mother Earth that have been pulled from her for your consumption. This is an exact and insidious contradiction to the meaning and purpose of crystal healing.
If you want to heal yourself, don’t use the damage of other to do so. Don’t take or steal or buy or commodify any piece of this planet to heal yourself. If you can find a beautiful stone, then pick it up and ask it’s name. Introduce yourself. Feel the stone in your palm, notice its texture. Put the rock or earthly mineral that you found into your pocket. (This also works with pieces of bark, or fallen leaves. Anything that was already available for your reciprocal healing and care.)
Carry it around for a few hours, maybe a few days. Bring it home with you, wherever that may be. Get to know it over the course of months and years. Pay reverence to the pieces of earth that you are asking to help you be a healthful human being upon our earth.
Only ever take a stone from a place where you are allowed to gather stones. Don’t pick up anything from a natural place where you’re not meant to, for the sake of the nature there. Your healing doesn’t mean the harming of another, not even another who doesn’t speak in human words.
If you believe in the powers of crystal healing, then you must believe in your responsibility to care for the crystals you already have. This is as serious as anything else. As we allow it to be true, it becomes true.
So be the guardian and steward of your already-bought gemstone pets. Be the mother to the stones that you took from your mother earth. It is your responsibility, as a human being. Care for second hand gems, if they happen to find you. Never buy any more new crystals.
No one can heal you if you are harming them.
Further Notes:
1 (for the crystal healer)
2 (for the influencer)
3 (for the skeptic)
1
To be clear, love and cherish the crystals you might already have. Treat them like wonderful pets or plants; care for their energy like you care for the hair, fur, roots, or leaves of other beings in your home. Tend to them, so they may tend to you. And, just to note, raw crystals and small crystals are sometimes more powerful. Not over-commodified objects, like polished pendants or massive bowls.
But stop buying them. Please, find ways to make your current life sacred.
Find other shiny things. Make non-shiny things shiny. Become shiny yourself and stop looking for more objects or extractions to feel that brilliance. If you want to work with minerals, use a sprinkle of salt. Be creative.
Or even channel the energy of a crystal you’ve learned about without having to buy it! Write poetry to the idea of the crystal, if you feel called. You can even draw a tiny rendition of a new crystal that you feel could be helpful and imbue it with the healing properties — without extracting it from it’s original home within our only earth. If you want to self-heal, then set your awareness compass to become wise about what health and healing truly means.
Also, (article foreshadowing) test your home for mold. Notice ways that you might be increasing your own daily fog, disorder, and chaos. Quit substances. Meditate. There are so many millions of actions we can take to improve the quality of ourselves and our lives.
Lucidity, health, and happiness go in waves, particularity within this horrific reality of trading time for survival (capitalism). Acceptance and silent meditation can help. If that feels daunting, find tiny little safe ways to feel a tiny bit better once in while.
2
For creators or spiritual influencers, please stop suggesting new crystals for people to buy.
Give us more non-consumption based rituals, healing techniques, or tools.
Give us ways to do better, be better, and become healthier that don’t involve more taking, buying, spending, purchase-hunting, shipping, seeking, owning, and otherwise objectifying this planet.
Or guide us to talk to trees instead. Or to find living plants in our neighborhood. Seek ways to teach us to preserve, conserve, allow, and breath into the world that we already inhabit, instead of finding more ways to have or add.
Enlightenment, in a crude summary, includes a clearing away of illusion, or excess, of that of our non-self. So, as healers and leaders, guide us toward that. Base your guidance in compassion and love — not a self-insular need, need, need, and telling us there’s more to purchase and use.
We all already have many, many objects at our disposal. Let us learn how to use our own hands, hearts, creativity, and the world around us instead.
3
Note: Although this might seem like a trivial or niche topic, the way that we interact with all aspects of our lives is interconnected with our treatment of ourselves, other humans, and our world overall.
I ask that we consider the macroscopic impact of our more nuanced or seemingly minute behaviors; that is one core reason that I’ve taken the time to write and then decided to publish this article, beyond the topic itself.
Throw-away culture and objectification (of tools that are also seen as energetically alive!) is just another facet of our disconnection to life and lack of awareness for self and others.
Deep thinking, lovingness, creative and open minded awareness, and self-wisdom are some primary antidotes to an isolated-topic mentality, in my experience.
Always be willing and ready to notice missing logical links, and to shift into something more healthy for all beings.
Find ways to create harmony, health, and congruence, with whatever that might require or inspire.
You’ll do great! No regret, fear, or worry. Only a determined and gentle self love to move forward with knowledge, awareness, kindness, and grace. I believe in your capacity and strength to find creative ways to survive and thrive with the tides of life, even in such a context as this. Let yourself rise to the challenge and create a life that feels wholesome and, ideally, safe.
Further readings:
- “Do You Know Where Your Healing Crystals Come From?”
by Emily Atkin for New Republic, published May 11th, 2018 - “The environmental impact of crystals // not so healing after all…”
by Gittemary Johansen, on Gittemary.com, September 16th, 2022 - “You’re Not Crazy. It’s Really Not Supposed to Be Like This.”
by Anna Mercury on Medium, published February 27th, 2023
[This article, despite using the complicated term “crazy,” is a fascinating primer describing why we are suffering to such extremes in today’s world. Not about crystal healing, but about the whole context within which we seek to self-heal, and an overall great read.]
Bonus:
“Are crystals the new blood diamonds?”
by Eva Wiseman, for The Guardian, published June 16th, 2019



.png)